What can I say, I watched "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl", and as much as I tried not liking it, I have to admit I really really did enjoyed the movie.
I know it has been said before (and I will say it again), that a movie based on the lamest, most boring ride at Disneyland (which I didn't particular care for myself - I want roller coasters not spinning teacups!) would actually turn out to be extremely entertaining and top notch.
I think the successful formula that made it work was that the people in charge made the movie for entertainment value alone - they had a gay old time so to speak. BUT the catch was they still in the end make a decent movie by not going overboard and camping it up. (ala "Batman & Robin").
We have all viewed those movies that had the formula of "It is a fun movie, not a serious one, so laugh dammit", but those movies still stink worse then a Slaughterhouse - in Florida - in July. It is difficult to pinpoint the exact magic formula they used that combined the two elements of "fun" and "good" together so well, but hey, they need to bottle that formula (and then sell it to Adam Sandler - PLEASE GOD give him a CLUE!!!)
Keira Knightly definitely is the breakout star of the movie, she provided life to what was a cliche paper-thin character and turned her into a corset wearing Xena for the 18th century (well a whalebone wearing corset anyway - we have all seen the leather one).
She is beautiful AND she has the talent and the gumption to become the next English Rose (move over Jane Seymour, shoo Kate Winslet). There is just so much to rave about her, but so little hours left in the evening to do so. She has the charisma to really carry a movie like this in her own right.
Orlando Bloom was fair enough, but he did come across as a weak link and just another pretty face (even though ironically his character was central to the plot). I guess they needed some Orlando 'ying' to Kiera's 'yang' (or would it be the other way around?)
Admittedly it was rather fun trying to spot his Elvish tattoo on his wrist. Even though they kept covering it up throughout the movie, it did appear at least partially in various scenes - like the original sword fight in the Black Smiths.
And okay... Johnny Depp. What can I say? He was amazing as Jack Sparrow. I guess I need to take back most of my pre-conceived notions of him. He isn't necessarily the dark brooding anti-hero that only ever plays characters more depressed and miserable then himself.
Pity he hasn't played more fun and light-hearted characters, he is really good at this particular style. Hopefully we will get to see more like this out of him. Heck, we know we will... he signed up for the sequel!!!
The only negative was the ending where I felt that Elizabeth and Will should’ve jumped into the water after Jack and went on with him living the pirate lifestyle. The ending given was a little to Disney-esque for me (I kept expecting Mickey and Donald to pop out and shake the Governors hand). But oh well, cannot win them all...
Maybe I should have seen this on the big screen; I definitely did miss out on seeing something spectacular. Cause everybody was a little boy (or girl) once, and what little boy (or girl) didn't at some stage want to be a pirate sailing the high seas chasing Spanish Galleon?